November 12, 2026
The data was relevant. The court said so. The request was denied anyway.
In FTC v. Uber, the FTC asked a federal magistrate judge to order Uber to produce ride and Uber Eats data for a 10% random sample of U.S. users from 2021 to 2026: times, locations, all components of price, discounts, and a data dictionary.
Was it relevant? “Oh, sure,” the October 15 order says.
But the request came about six weeks before fact discovery was set to close, and the court found that pulling together what was likely billions of transactions in that window was not proportional to the needs of the case. “Had the FTC filed this motion to compel earlier in fact discovery,” the judge wrote, “the Court might have granted it.”
Two weeks later, the picture changed. The fact discovery deadline was extended by a month. The FTC narrowed its request to a 1% sample and offered to leave out data from before 2023 if Uber confirmed it was stored separately. On October 30, the court granted the narrowed request.
In hindsight, a middle answer was available from the start: a smaller sample, a shorter period. Reaching it took a denial, a new schedule and a second round of briefing.
The case is a government enforcement action, and it continues.
In a private dispute, the same path can follow unless the parties reach a narrower scope—smaller sample, defined fields, realistic production window—through discussion before the first motion. A neutral can help them do that while there is still time on the calendar.
Relevance makes the data matter. Timing often decides how much of it anyone sees.
Sources
FTC v. Uber Technologies, Inc., No. 25-cv-03477-JST (TSH) (N.D. Cal.).
ECF No. 281, Discovery Order (October 15, 2026).
ECF No. 294, Order extending case schedule (October 22, 2026).
ECF No. 307, Discovery Order granting reconsideration (October 30, 2026).
Ariadne Latorre is a Florida Supreme Court certified mediator and a software engineer. She mediates business and commercial, insurance and risk allocation, LegalTech and information governance, HOA and community, and court-ordered matters, in English and Spanish, in Miami and virtually worldwide.